Which shingle is better, malarkey or CertainTeed?

Deciding which shingle is better between Malarkey and CertainTeed depends on your priorities, as both are premium brands with different strengths. Malarkey is often considered better for impact resistance, cold weather flexibility, and sustainability. Malarkey Vista and Legacy feature Flexor SBS polymer-modified asphalt that provides superior flexibility in cold weather, preventing cracking and allowing installation in colder temperatures, plus Class 4 impact resistance rating for hail, and Scotchgard Protector algae protection from 3M with lifetime algae warranty. Malarkey also uses upcycled rubber and plastic for sustainability. CertainTeed is considered better for heavier weight, richer color depth, and designer options. CertainTeed Landmark is heavier at 240 to 270 pounds per square versus Malarkey Vista at 240 pounds, and is known for deeper, richer colors and excellent granule retention. CertainTeed offers more premium designer lines like Grand Manor and Presidential Shake that mimic slate and wood shake better than Malarkey's designer options. Both offer lifetime limited warranties defined as 50 years and strong wind warranties at 110 to 130 mph. Price wise, Malarkey is 10 to 20 percent more expensive at 120 to 180 dollars per square versus CertainTeed Landmark at 100 to 160 dollars. For hail-prone and cold climates where flexibility and impact resistance matter, Malarkey is better. For heavier weight and more luxury designer looks, CertainTeed is better.