Between Malarkey Vista and Legacy, Legacy is considered the better shingle overall, offering thicker, more dimensional appearance and enhanced durability, while Vista is better for budget-conscious premium projects. Both Malarkey Vista and Legacy are excellent architectural shingles made with Flexor SBS polymer-modified asphalt that provides superior flexibility in cold weather, Class 4 impact resistance for hail, and Scotchgard Protector algae protection with lifetime algae warranty. Vista is the entry-level premium line, weighing around 240 pounds per square, offering good dimensional appearance, 110 mph wind warranty, and costing around 120 to 150 dollars per square materials. Legacy is the upgraded premium line, weighing around 270 to 300 pounds per square, offering thicker, more dimensional appearance with richer shadow lines, heavier weight for better durability, 130 mph wind warranty, and costing around 140 to 180 dollars per square materials. Legacy also has enhanced granule retention and more vibrant color options. Both have lifetime limited warranty, but Legacy is often considered better for curb appeal and long-term performance. For homeowners wanting excellent Malarkey performance at lower cost, Vista is good value. For homeowners wanting the best appearance, heaviest weight, and highest wind rating from Malarkey, Legacy is better and worth the extra 10 to 20 percent cost. Most contractors recommend Legacy as the better overall investment.
1 votes
Marked as accepted