Who is better, State Farm or American Family?

Accident Fund Insurance Company of America 27 American International Group (AIG) 27 Country Financial 13 GEICO 23 Gerber Life Insurance Company 23 Harvard Pilgrim Health Care 20 Horace Mann Educators Corporation 27 Merchants Insurance Group 10 New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Company 19 New York State Insurance Fund 28 Omega 33 Philadelphia Contributionship for the Insurance of Houses from Loss by Fire 22 Physicians Mutual 21 SquareTrade 24 Standard Insurance Company 20 The Norfolk & Dedham Group 16 TIAA-CREF 13 UNIFI Companies 33 West Coast Life 10 White Mountains Insurance Group 23