Which brand of shingles is better, Pabco or Malarkey?

Both PABCO and Malarkey are respected West Coast shingle manufacturers, and which is better depends on priorities, but most contractors rank Malarkey as slightly better overall for premium performance, while PABCO offers better value. PABCO Roofing Products, based in Fife, Washington since 1945, makes PABCO Premier and Paramount architectural shingles that are good quality, mid-tier, with AlgaeBlock algae protection, 110 to 130 mph wind rating, limited lifetime warranty, and competitive pricing around 110 to 150 per bundle, focusing on value and reliable performance in Pacific Northwest climates. Malarkey Roofing Products, based in Portland, Oregon since 1956, is considered a premium innovator, making Legacy, Vista, and Highlander shingles with SBS modified rubberized asphalt that is more flexible in cold and impact resistant, plus NEX polymer modified technology for durability, Class 4 impact rating on Legacy, and Scotchgard algae protection from 3M, with wind ratings up to 160 mph and superior hail resistance, but priced higher at 140 to 190 per bundle. Malarkey is known for longer lifespan and better performance in hail and extreme weather, often recommended for best quality on West Coast. PABCO is better for budget-conscious homeowners wanting good quality at lower cost. So if you want best performance and premium durability, Malarkey Legacy is better, if you want best value good quality at lower price, PABCO Premier is better.